Inevitable Messi, rejuvenated Suárez lead Inter Miami's first-half player ratings

It's no surprise that Leo Messi has the team's highest FotMob score and my highest grade. He's won the last two MLS Most Valuable Player awards -- the first ever to win the honor in consecutive years -- and already has 20 goal contributions (12 goals, 8 assists) in 2026. It's probably more surprising to see Messi's long-time amigo Luis Suárez with the team's second-best grade -- it surprised me, to be honest. But "El Pistolero" is in better shape than he was a year ago, has had a positive attitude about his benching at the end of last season and early this campaign, and has continued to work hard and make an offensive difference when he does play. I was one of the fans who thought Suárez was done, but he's been invaluable to Los Garzas since Hoyos put him back in the starting lineup.

Who else made the grade? Below I share a brief thought about each of the Herons:

Yannick Bright (A-) -- Continues to develop as one of the best young defensive midfielders in MLS.

Telasco Segovia (A-) -- Has become an integral part of the Herons' lineup, good on the ball, in sync with Messi, Suárez and Berterame around the goal and providing defensive support and link-up play through the midfield.

Mateo Silvetti (A-) -- Limited somewhat by injuries, but when he's on the pitch, he gives the Herons much needed pace and dynamic attacking from out wide.

Ian Fray (B+) -- The Heron homegrown has again earned the starting right wing back role and played well, but in recent matches he's shown the kind of volatility and lack of self-discipline that can hurt the team in crucial situations. Still, his future looks very bright.

Gonzalo Luján (B+) -- Luján has been impressively strong in 2026 after being wildly inconsistent -- or consistently poor -- a season ago. His improvement has been a pleasant surprise considering Falcón's regression.

Micael (B+) -- Has performed much as advertised, providing stability and a strong physical presence on the back line.

Noah Allen (B) -- Maybe my favorite Heron, another homegrown player who has become a consistent contributor. He's probably better suited to play center back but is a serviceable left wing who filled in nicely while Sergio Reguilón dealt with injuries early in the season.

Rodrigo De Paul (B) -- Probably deserves a higher rating, but his constant whining and yelling at his teammates -- except Messi or Suárez -- is off-putting. He has played much better since Bright and Segovia have been added to the lineup, relieving most of his defensive responsibilities.

Germán Berterame (C+) -- Brought in from Monterrey on a $15 million transfer fee, Berte is a striker -- a designated player -- who has struggled to score goals. But he works tirelessly on defense, creating turnovers with his high pressing, and he seems finally to be finding his finishing touch. Berterame may have more room to improve than any player on this list.

Facundo Mura (C) -- I'm still not sure who or what Mura is; he can play both wings, but so far hasn't stood out in a positive or negative manner. He seems very average.

Dayne St. Clair (C) -- Another disappointment. The defending MLS Goalkeeper of the Year and possible World Cup starter for Canada was thrown into an entirely different tactical world -- from low-block, defensive-minded Minnesota to high-pressing, attack-minded Miami -- and hasn't fully adapted.

Maxi Falcón (C-) -- "El Peluca" -- the Wig -- was a starter much of 2025 and was the club's most effective center back down the stretch and through the playoffs, but has been overly aggressive and undisciplined in 2026, ultimately losing his spot in the 11 to Luján .

Tadeo Allende (D) -- The playoff hero (a record 9 goals and 2 assists in six matches) hasn't scored in 2026 and is recovering from knee surgery. Many supporters wrote off the speedy winger's performance a fluke, expecting a return to his frustrating ineffectiveness from the last regular season. I want them to be wrong, but so far Allende hasn't shown anywhere near the same spark.

"

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow